It happens again and again. There is a food that the public eats — one that mankind has consumed for a very long time.
Someone publishes research that associates that food with a negative health effect. The experts tell everyone to avoid that food, and everyone freaks out. Eggs are tossed into the harbor. Fat is burned in effigy. Shakers of salt are smashed in public squares.
Now soy is having its panic-in-the-streets moment.
The humble soybean has been accused of everything from causing breast cancer to damaging the thyroid to flooding men and women with estrogen. Is soy a monster bent on destroying mankind? Is it a misunderstood ally of the human race? Let’s try to get to the bottom of the bean.
"When I talk about soy in class, I talk about it like beer. If you’re an adult and you go out and have one or two beers, you can expect not to have any serious adverse health outcomes. If you drink 10, then you’re going to have a problem."
- Heather B. Patisaul, associate professor at North Carolina State University
Doesn't Soy Contain Phytoestrogens?
One of the knocks against soy is that it contains phytoestrogens, a group of natural compounds that resemble estrogen organically.
According to Heather B. Patisaul of North Carolina State University and Wendy Jefferson of the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, whose review “The Pros and Cons of Phytoestrogen” was published in Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology, the jury is still out on phytoestrogens. Patisaul and Jefferson wrote: “A litany of health benefits including a lowered risk of osteoporosis, heart disease, breast cancer and menopausal symptoms are frequently attributed to phytoestrogens, but many are also considered endocrine disruptors, indicating that they have the potential to cause adverse health effects as well. Consequently, the question of whether or not phytoestrogens are beneficial or harmful to human health remains unresolved.” (Endocrine disruptors are chemicals that may interfere with the body’s endocrine system and produce adverse effects.)
The researchers say soy’s effects are most likely complex and could depend on the age, health status and even the presence or absence of specific gut microflora in the individual. So what’s a phytoestrogen-wary individual to do?
“It’s all things in moderation,” said Patisaul, an associate professor at North Carolina State. “When I talk about soy in class, I talk about it like beer. If you’re an adult and you go out and have one or two beers, you can expect not to have any serious adverse health outcomes. If you drink 10, then you’re going to have a problem. It sort of depends on your life stage and how much you’re consuming and what other types of health issues you have.”
Many non-meat-eaters prefer soy because it’s a complete protein.
Patisaul cautions that soy should not be the only protein a person eats — it should be one of many. Why? Too much soy causes problems for some people. In a small number of cases women ate so much soy it suppressed their menstrual cycles and acted like a birth-control pill. The remedy, of course, was simple: Eat less soy.
The most damning research on endocrine disruption comes from studying animals, and it’s a body of work many have called into question. For example, some studies use only newborn mice, and instead of eating phytoestrogens, the mice are injected with them, bypassing normal metabolic pathways.
Phytoestrogens might do some good, and they might do some bad, particularly when consumed in vast quantities. What, for example, are phytoestrogen’s effects on the thyroid and breasts? Researchers are busy answering those questions.
Can Soy Affect Thyroid Function?
The thyroid is an endocrine gland that makes hormones, which control the rate of many metabolic activities in the body. A 2006 review of 14 trials by researchers from Loma Linda University published in the journal Thyroid looked at the effects of soy food on at least one measure of thyroid function in healthy humans. The review revealed that soy and its isoflavones, a class of phytoestrogens, present little evidence of adversely affecting thyroid function. The study was written by Mark Messina, who, in addition to being a Loma Linda University professor and internationally recognized expert on the health effects of soy, is also a consultant for companies that manufacture and/or sell soy food.
A three-year study of postmenopausal women in Italy published in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism in 2010 exposed participants to large amounts of isoflavones and evaluated conventional as well as sensitive markers of thyroid function. No effect on thyroid function was found.
But researchers are still searching for connections.
For example, in 2011 a British team published a study that connected phytoestrogen with thyroid function. Sixty people with subclinical hypothyroidism (mild thyroid failure) were randomly assigned either a typical Western dose of phytoestrogen (2 mg) or a dose that coincides with a vegetarian diet (16 mg). Six participants (10 percent) progressed from subclinical to overt hypothyroidism after consuming the higher dose; no one on the lower dose had further development of thyroid issues. The study also found a significant reduction in systolic and diastolic blood pressure, insulin resistance and inflammation with the higher dosage. This study adds weight to Patisaul’s recommendation that moderation is important for people who choose to consume soy.
Is Soy Connected With Breast Cancer?
Soy is not a known cause of breast cancer. In fact, the American Cancer Society calls soy “an excellent source of protein and a good alternative to meat.” But estrogen plays a major role in breast cancer, which is why researchers are interested in revealing how soy and its phytoestrogens affect breast cancer survivors.
A 2001 study published in the Annals of Pharmacotherapy found that low concentrations of genistein and daidzein, the major phytoestrogens in soy, stimulated breast tumor growth in animals. Genistein and daidzein also antagonized the antitumor effect of the breast cancer drug tamoxifen in the lab. The researchers concluded: “Genistein and daidzein may stimulate existing breast tumor growth and antagonize the effects of tamoxifen. Women with current or past breast cancer should be aware of the risks of potential tumor growth when taking soy products.”
Some people might read that and say, “OK, well, this stuff must be bad for you.” But contrary to that animal study, a body of research on humans says soy might help prevent breast cancer and reduce its recurrence, or it might have no effect at all.
University of Southern California researchers, funded by the California Breast Cancer Research Program and by a grant from the National Cancer Institute, found that observational studies showed a decreased risk of breast cancer development in association with high intake of soy. Clinical and intervention studies on the short-term effects of soy products, however, have not shown clear beneficial or harmful effects.
The American Cancer Society says: “There is growing evidence that eating traditional soy foods such as tofu may lower the risk of cancers of the breast, prostate, or endometrium, and there is some evidence it may lower the risk of certain other cancers. Whether this applies to foods that contain soy protein isolates or textured vegetable protein derived from soy is not known. There is little data to support the use of supplements of isolated soy phytochemicals for reducing cancer risk.”
If there is a firm link between soy and lowering the risk of breast cancer development, it has yet to be established. A Chinese study, for example, suggests that soy isoflavones are associated with a “significant” reduced risk of breast cancer incidence only in Asian populations and not in their Western counterparts.
Vanderbilt University professor of cancer research Xiao Ou Shu has studied the link between soy and breast cancer prognosis. Her research has consistently found that soy food intake does not harm breast cancer survivors and may be associated with a reduced risk of recurrence and mortality. “It’s safe for breast cancer survivors and potentially beneficial,” Shu said.
To receive benefits from soy, it should be eaten whole. The effect of soy isoflavone supplements has not been fully evaluated in humans. “Soy contains high levels of isoflavones, which has often been postulated to explain this potential benefit. However, soy also has many more nutrients and phytochemicals that have known anticancer properties,” Shu said. “We studied soy as a whole food and cannot disentangle the effects of isoflavones from effects of other constituents in the soy. Thus, we can only make a recommendation for soy food. The safety and effectiveness of soy isoflavone supplementation needs to be evaluated.”
As for teens, research suggests that soy foods or an exposure to the soy isoflavone genistein during childhood and adolescence in women, as well as before puberty in animals, reduces mammary cancer risk later in life.
What About Soy and Men?
A 2010 meta-analysis of 15 studies found that neither soy foods nor isoflavone supplements alter measures of testosterone concentrations. A 2013 study concluded that short-term intake of soy isoflavones does not affect serum hormone levels, total cholesterol or prostate-specific antigen, which is present in small quantities in the serum of men with healthy prostates.
And What About Soy Allergies?
Soy induces an allergic reaction in a small portion of the population. Some babies, for example, are allergic to soy-based formula. Most children lose their allergy as they age, but soy allergies also can spring up during adulthood. There is good news for soy eaters with soy allergies: Fermented soy may cause drastically fewer allergic reactions. In 2008, University of Illinois researchers revealed that fermented soy reduces potential allergenicity and increases essential amino acids.
The Trouble With Highly Processed Soy, a.k.a. Soy Protein Isolate
Sales of soy foods in the United States crossed the $5.2 billion mark in 2011. Today, processed soy protein (in the form of soy protein isolate) is used in protein bars, breakfast cereals, salad dressings, soups, cheeses, nondairy creamers, whipped toppings and infant formulas. Some doctors and nutritionists — among them Dr. Caldwell Esselstyn Jr. of the Cleveland Clinic; Dr. Dean Ornish, Dr. Andrew Weil and Dr. Mark Hyman; and Ashley Koff, a registered dietitian and co-author of “Mom Energy: A Simple Plan To Live Fully Charged” — recommend avoiding foods containing soy protein isolate, including fake meats, soy cheeses and protein bars. Weil, Hyman and Koff have spoken out to say that these highly processed soy products do not have the health benefits of whole natural soy. Koff has expressed concern that soy protein isolate may disrupt hormones.
Dr. Mark Hyman urges his website readers to “say no to processed soy products” because “they don’t have the thousands of years of traditional use that whole soy foods do, they’re processed, and they contain unhealthy fats and other compounds.”
Dietitian and author Ashley Koff is quoted in an April 2012 post on Time's blog Healthland as saying, “I won’t eat soy protein isolate or, for that matter, any soy unless it’s in its organic whole-food form. Isolating the protein at the very least removes the benefits of the rest of the soy (like its fiber and omega-3s) and at worst creates a product that may be implicated in hormone imbalance.”
Almost All Soy Is Genetically Modified (GMO)
You’ve probably heard that most soy in the United States is genetically modified, and it’s true. Soybeans were among the first FDA-approved genetically modified organisms during the mid-1990s. By 2012, 93 percent of soy grown in the United States was genetically modified, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
Some people worry that genetically modified soy is unhealthy, citing Russian research that claims it causes infertility in hamsters. That particular piece of research was unpublished, meaning it was not exposed to a standard peer-review process. The organizations that conducted the research are not well-known. Articles and blog posts that cited the study failed to provide a link to the study itself. In conclusion: That research failed to meet the minimum standards of accountability and should not be taken seriously.
There might not be hard proof that genetically modified soy is bad, but are all GMOs unhealthy? The answer is unclear at this point. What we do know with certainty is that GMOs are highly controversial, with some polls finding that more than half of the American public believes GMOs are unsafe and many countries banning them outright. A nationwide June 2013 ABC News phone poll of 1,024 American adults found that barely more than a third of the public believes genetically modified foods are safe to eat. Fifty-two percent believe such foods are unsafe, and an additional 13 percent are unsure about them.
As of 2013, at least 26 countries — including Australia, Austria, Bulgaria, China, India, Italy, France, Germany, Mexico, Russia and Switzerland — had total or partial bans on GMOs.
However, major scientific bodies, such as the World Health Organization, believe that GMOs currently on the market are not likely to present any risk to humans. The WHO writes on its website: “Individual GM foods and their safety should be assessed on a case-by-case basis, and it is not possible to make general statements on the safety of all GM foods. GM foods currently available on the international market have passed risk assessments and are not likely to present risks for human health. In addition, no effects on human health have been shown as a result of the consumption of such foods by the general population in the countries where they have been approved. Continuous use of risk assessments based on the Codex principles and, where appropriate, including post-market monitoring, should form the basis for evaluating the safety of GM foods.”
So, Are There Any Benefits to Eating Soy?
Soy is a complete plant protein that contains all the essential amino acids. Whole soy (such as steamed edamame beans) and fermented soy (in the form of miso, tempeh and some types of tofu) have long been staples of Asian diets. Populations that consume whole and fermented soy, such as those in East Asia, have been proven to have less breast cancer, prostate cancer and cardiovascular disease, as well as fewer bone fractures. Women report fewer menopausal symptoms, and both sexes have a lower incidence of age-related brain diseases. Interestingly, when Asians immigrate to Western nations, including the United States, and adopt the native cuisine, their disease rates change.
Soy Is a Cheap Crop That Is Ubiquitous in Our Food Supply
Are there problems with soy? Yes, and the ones we know about are manmade. Soybeans are massively subsidized, which means it’s cheaper for farmers to produce soy compared to other foods. So that’s one problem: Potentially healthier foods are being crowded out of the market by Big Soybean.
The other problem is that when a food is cheap, food manufacturers stick it in everything. Highly processed soy is stripped of its nutritional value, and it winds up in manufactured foods that often are less healthy than whole foods.
If you decide to consume soy after weighing the pros and cons, for the full benefits choose whole soy (such as steamed edamame) or fermented soy (such as miso or tempeh), and minimize your intake of highly processed soy contained in many packaged energy bars, shakes and foods like fake meats, soy cheeses and soy ice creams. Be sure to check the labels.
If you are looking to avoid GMOs, choose organic soy. Organic products, by law, must be GMO-free. Also, you may want to heed Patisaul’s recommendation about moderation with regard to your soy consumption.
READERS – WHAT DO YOU THINK? DO YOU EAT SOY OR AVOID IT? IF YOU DON’T EAT IT, WHAT IS THE REASON? ARE YOU CONCERNED ABOUT GMOs? DID YOU ALREADY KNOW ALL OF THIS INFORMATION ABOUT SOY? IS THERE ANYTHING IMPORTANT THAT WE MISSED IN THIS ARTICLE? LEAVE A COMMENT BELOW AND LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THINK.
Joe Donatelli is a freelance journalist. Contact him at www.joedonatelli.com.
- Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology: The Pros and Cons of Phytoestrogen
- Thyroid: Effects of Soy Protein and Soybean Isoflavones on Thyroid Function in Healthy Adults and Hypothyroid Patients: A Review of the Relevant Literature
- Genistein aglycone does not affect thyroid function: results from a three-year, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial.
- Jouranl of the American College of Nutrition: The Symbolization of Eggs in American Culture: A Sociologic Analysis
- American Cancer Society
- Effects of soy phytoestrogens genistein and daidzein on breast cancer growth.
- Soy Isoflavones and Breast Cancer
- Soy isoflavones consumption and risk of breast cancer incidence or recurrence: a meta-analysis of prospective studies.
- Soy food intake after diagnosis of breast cancer and survival: an in-depth analysis of combined evidence from cohort studies of US and Chinese women.
- The role of early life genistein exposures in modifying breast cancer risk.