Recumbent Vs Upright Bike

Recumbent Vs Upright Bike
Photo Credit bike ride image by Andrew Breeden from Fotolia.com

Although the majority of people you see on bikes are riding the traditional upright bikes, it is becoming more and more common to see people riding recumbent bikes. Upright bikes are the diamond-frame bikes that most people grow up learning to ride. Recumbent bikes are usually longer and lower to the ground. You ride while seated in a reclined position rather than leaning forward like on an upright bike. In some cases, the handles are located in front of the rider, but in others they are located at the sides of the seat. Frames come in both long and short versions, depending on the design of the bike. Each type of bike has advantages and disadvantages, which should be considered when choosing a bike.

Comfort

One of the benefits of riding a recumbent bicycle is a more comfortable seating arrangement that spreads out your body weight, which is particularly important for people with stress injuries and such conditions as arthritis. Upright bikes concentrate all your body weight in your seat and your hands and wrists, and also force you to sit with a forward bend and to put your neck at an uncomfortable angle in order to look forward while riding.
Some people have issues with riding recumbent bicycles uphill. They end up putting a lot of pressure on their knees, which then get sore. More experienced riders know to pedal more and use a lower gear to combat this problem. However, many people find it easier to go up hills with an upright bike because you can stand and use your whole body weight to get added power to help push you up hills.

Safety

Recumbent bikes are sometimes considered to be safer because you don't have as far to fall and don't flip over the bike if you crash. The novelty also makes them more likely to be seen by drivers. Riders of recumbent bicycles have a better view of their surroundings to the front and the sides than those riding upright bikes.
With upright bikes, you are more visible to drivers due to the higher profile of the rider. It is also easier to look behind you when riding these bikes. Recumbent riders try to make up for these safety issues by using mirrors to make it easier to look behind them and putting flags on their bikes to make them more visible to people driving vehicles.

Other Differences

People who are interested in going fast should know that you can go faster on a recumbent bike. In fact, riders of recumbent bikes hold the land speed records for bicycles. The lower profiles of these bikes make it so that there is less wind resistance, making it easier to go faster.
Other advantages of riding upright bikes include the fact that they are lighter, as well as being less expensive because they are mass produced rather than being made individually like many recumbent bikes. You can carry more with you on an upright bike as well because you can use panniers in the front and the back rather than just the back like on recumbent bicycles.

Considerations

People who get sore riding upright bikes or who have conditions that make it uncomfortable for them to ride these bikes should consider recumbent bikes, according to Dr. Paul Nolan. In his article "Medical Benefits of Recumbent Bikes," he says that the riding position of a recumbent puts the body in a more anatomically correct position, with the body weight spread out between the back and behind, the arms relaxed, the neck comfortable with the head looking forward and the legs in a more relaxed resting position.

Expert Insight

When it comes to recumbent bikes versus upright bikes, there is no clear answer on which is better, they are just different, according to an article on BicyclingLife.com. People who like trail riding might be better off with an upright bike, while those who like to tour might be more comfortable if they used a recumbent bike. People with injuries or those who are not comfortable riding upright bikes might be able to continue enjoying bike riding if they give recumbent bikes a try.

References

Article reviewed by Grygor Scott Last updated on: Feb 9, 2012

Must see: Photo Galleries

Member Comments