Do Mini Stationary Bikes Provide a Good Workout?

Mini exercise bikes, also known as pedal exercisers, come in fairly low on the spectrum of benefits received versus time invested. Some exercise is certainly better than none, and mini exercisers do have a few things working in their favor. But there are more reasons to opt for other types of equipment than to use a mini bike.

Description

Most mini bikes are either sold as attachments for home gyms, enabling you to add cardio training to your exercise program, or as stand-alone models promoted for their portability. The stand-alone models are usually little more than a flywheel shrouded in a cover, two pedals, and a knob to twist for more or less resistance. The add-on mini bike attachments look about the same, but include a connector to attach to the home gym.

Range of Motion

Mini bikes work the same large muscles of your lower body as a regular exercise bike -- quads, hamstrings, glutes and, to a very limited degree, calves. But the mini bike's pedal crank arms are too short to offer a full range of motion. Since you don't work your muscles through the same range of motion as on a regular bike, your muscular endurance will only improve within the limited range of motion the mini bike allows.

Specificity

Put very simply, the principle of sports specificity states that you get better at what you practice. Although cross training is beneficial, if you want to be a pro soccer player you're going to have to practice soccer. If you want to be a powerful cyclist, you can train on a real bike or on a stationary bike. But since the mini bike's movement isn't the same as a real cycling motion, it's of minimal use in preparing you for real cycling.

Intensity

The mini bike only provides a "good" workout, as defined by the American College of Sports Medicine, or ACMS, if it meets the ACSM's definition of moderate-intensity exercise. You should break a sweat, have an elevated heart rate, but still be able to carry on a conversation. The bike might provide enough resistance for moderate exercise when you first start out -- so it could provide a good workout, at least for a while. But as you get stronger, the mini cycle will no longer be able to provide you with the moderate intensity you need for an efficient workout.

Considerations

Although the mini bikes offer a limited workout, with a limited range of resistance levels to choose from, they do serve a purpose. Evaluate the bikes in relation to your own capabilities. If you enjoy the bike enough to use it regularly, that automatically makes it a worthwhile investment. Again, some exercise is better than none, and a less-than-perfect machine you're willing to use will often motivate you to exercise more than the perfect exercise machine that you despise. Likewise, if you have extremely limited money and space, the mini bike might be your ideal exercise solution -- for the time being.

References

Article reviewed by Roman Tsivkin Last updated on: Oct 28, 2010

Must see: Photo Galleries

Member Comments