How to Evaluate Diets

In a weight-obsessed world, it can be confusing to decide which diet is the best for you. It seems like there are new diets and fads introduced daily, and knowing which is right for you might be difficult. Evaluating a diet carefully can give you greater insights into its philosophies, and can tell you whether it would be compatible with your lifestyle. Finding a good diet plan may be trial and error, and you may need to evaluate several before you find the one that will give you the best results.

Step 1

Choose a diet to evaluate. Instead of choosing one at random, pick one that you know a little about, one that you think that would work well with your lifestyle and habits, and one that you think will give you good results. See the Resources section for a list of potential diet plans to evaluate.

Step 2

Compare the claims of the diet plan to other plans and common sense. If the diet claims to help you lose 10 pounds in two days, it may be unreasonable and set you up for failure with false claims or unhealthy weight loss methods. Remember that healthy weight loss is a pound per week, according to the United States National Library of Medicine.

Step 3

Read the information and material that comes with the diet plan. To evaluate properly, you must be sure that you are educated about the different concepts of the diet plan, so you can be sure to give it a fair evaluation based on clear instructions that are presented to you.

Step 4

Live and follow the diet plan for at least 30 days for an accurate evaluation. Keep a diet journal and record things like the amount of weight lost per week, how you felt while on the diet, things you liked about the diet plan and things you didn't like. It might also be helpful to keep a list of foods that were eaten.

Step 5

Evaluate the diet at the end of 30 days by reading through your findings and deciding if the amount of weight loss was equal to the amount of effort that was expended in following the plan. A good diet plan is sensible but effective. If the diet you've evaluated only gives minimal weight loss with too much work, try another diet until you find one that gives you satisfactory loss with an average amount of effort.

Things You'll Need

  • Diet journal

References

Article reviewed by Carolyn Williams Last updated on: Oct 27, 2009

Must see: Photo Galleries

Member Comments