There is no difference in the number of calories burned on a cross trainer, bike or treadmill if you maintain the same heart rate on all three machines. However, your perceived intensity required to maintain a given heart rate may vary for each piece of equipment.
Accurate calculation of calories burned per hour factors in body weight. As body mass increases so does the heart rate and number of calories burned per hour. In addition, as your physical fitness level increases the calories you burn per hour decrease.
The pace you maintain on a treadmill determines the number of calories you will burn. For example, a 155-pound person walking at 3.5 miles per hour burns 356 calories per hour. If the same person walks 4.5 miles per hour, he will burn 444 calories per hour.
Using a stationary bike burns fewer calories than biking outdoors. A 155-pound person exerting a moderate amount of energy will burn 420 calories per hour on a stationary bike versus 480 calories while bicycling outdoors.
When you use a cross trainer, also known as an elliptical, you decrease the impact on your bones and joints. Because you engage many more muscle groups, you may burn more calories at a lower level of perceived exertion compared to a bike or treadmill. A 155-pound person using a cross trainer for an hour at moderate intensity burns 570 calories.
- Harvard Health Publications; Calories Burned In 30 Minutes For People of Three Different Weights
- "The Cardio-Free Diet"; Jim Karas; 2008