A superficial look at soccer shoes and baseball cleats shows little difference between the two, but there are significant construction differences that affect the comfort, safety and performance of players. The two types of shoes are not easily interchangeable between sports. While soccer shoes can be worn for baseball in a pinch, some types of baseball cleats are banned from use in soccer games.
Cleat Type
Baseball and soccer shoes have two different basic designs. Shoes with molded cleats have cleats on the soles that are not removable and are part of the sole. Detachable or interchangeable cleats are screwed into the sole and are designed to be replaced. Advanced athletes often favor detachable cleats, which allow for tailoring shoes to different playing surfaces. The biggest difference in cleats between the shoes is the presence of a toe cleat. In baseball shoes, a cleat is located directly under the toes. There is no toe cleat on soccer shoes and shoes with toe cleats are not allowed in soccer games for safety considerations.
Cleat Material
The cleats on soccer shoes are made of hard plastic or rubber. Some detachable cleats are hard plastic tipped with metal. Baseball cleats are also made of hard plastic and are usually the only kind allowed for younger players. Older players often wear shoes with metal spikes, which offer a better grip on hard surfaces. Most professional baseball players use metal spikes.
Construction
Both types of shoes come in synthetic materials or leather. The material used for soccer shoes tends to be lighter and more flexible to allow for greater range of movement. Soccer shoes are cut low to keep the ankle free, due to the rapid and frequent changes of direction soccer players need to make. Baseball shoes are generally mid-topped or high-topped to provide support to the ankles when making quick starts.
Considerations
Beginning players in both sports need shoes that fit comfortably and provide the correct type of support and cleat type, but they don't need shoes made of leather which tend to be more expensive. Interchangeable cleats are also not recommended for beginners and are not even allowed for most youth leagues. Intermediate and advanced players should think about the type of surface they will be playing on regularly when choosing shoes. Plastic cleats provide good traction on most surfaces, particularly on grass, but metal spikes or metal tipped cleats are good for harder surfaces.
Member Comments