Erythritol Vs. Stevia Vs. Xylitol

Erythritol Vs. Stevia Vs. Xylitol
Photo Credit Comstock/Comstock/Getty Images

As obesity, diabetes and heart disease incidence rates increase each year, consumers are looking to alternatives such as sugar alcohols and sugar substitutes to aid in weight management. Erythritol and xylitol -- two sugar alcohols -- and stevia, an herb-based sugar substitute, are ingredients found in many food products on grocery store shelves. As all three are associated with health benefits, consumers can rest assured foods manufactured with these ingredients are safe for consumption.

What are Sugar Alcohols?

When you flip over the package of sugar-free chewing gum, mouthwash, mints, or cough drops, you may notice several ingredients ending in "ol." These ingredients are sugar alcohols, found naturally in the fibrous components of many fruits and vegetables. Through hydrogenation, manufacturers adapt sugar alcohols by adding a hydrogen atom; the result is a product that is sweet and partially indigestible by the body. The advantage is sweetness similar to sugar at a fraction of the calorie content.

Erythritol

Erythritol, a common ingredient in chewing gums, can decrease the incidence of dental caries or cavities. Chewing sugar-free gum manufactured with erythritol stimulates the production of saliva, which decreases the cavity-promoting effects of sugar. Unlike products with many other sugar alcohols, products sweetened with erythritol have little gastrointestinal effect when consumed in greater quantities.

Xylitol

Xylitol also has prevention-cavity actions, and many dentists recommend it also for its ability to remineralize and strengthen teeth and gums. Like erythritol, xylitol offers sweetness at far fewer calories than sucrose or table sugar. This sugar alcohol is also available in packet form to use in everyday sweetening of beverages. A common complaint, however, as with most sugar alcohols, is bloating and diarrhea.

Stevia

A fairly new addition to the sugar substitute world, stevia is making its way into more food products as a healthy, more natural alternative to sugar. Extracted as an herb from a small shrub native to South America, stevia offers sweetness at a fraction of the calories in sugar. Stevia is used more commonly used in drink mixes, food products and beverages. With no apparent gastrointestinal complications, stevia may offer a reasonable alternative to xylitol for beverages.

References

Article reviewed by joyce sexton Last updated on: Jul 21, 2011

Must see: Photo Galleries

Member Comments