The Lat Pulldown vs. the Straight-Arm Pulldown

The Lat Pulldown vs. the Straight-Arm Pulldown
Photo Credit Brand X Pictures/Brand X Pictures/Getty Images

Pulldowns are workouts designed to stimulate and strengthen your lat muscles that run alongside your outer back. There are alternative versions to this workout. A traditional pulldown is performed while seated while with a straight arm pulldown workout you typically go into a standing position. Though these workouts are in essence the same, they work the muscles from a slightly different angle. Working your lat muscles will make them thicker and wider.

Straight-Arm Pulldown

The straight arm pulldown is the standing version of the laterial pulldown. Before you start, you need to set the equipment up properly. Choose a weight that is a bit less that your laterial pulldown, since the angle is a bit different. Face the machine, and grab hold of the overhanging bar with a shoulder-width grip. Step two or three feet back with your knees slightly bend. Pull the weight down slowing, rotating only the shoulders but keeping everything else in place. This exercise is better for isolation the lats.

Lat Pulldown

There are two versions of the seated pulldowns. It is an exercise mainly focusing on the back muscles, but your shoulders and arms get a workout as well. A pulldown machine consists of a bar suspended by a cord that is attached to a stack of weights. A seat is positioned directly underneath the bar. Sit down on the chair, taking hold of the bar with your wrists facing forward. Pull the bar down towards your chest. Make sure that your arms are parallel to your chest, while your elbows are lowered towards your ribs.

Considerations

When you do the straight arm pulldown, focus on your lat muscles when doing the pulling. Both exercises should focus on the lats and not the arms, so mind your form. The smaller muscles can’t take the strain that the lat muscles can. Always move the bars in slow controlled motions. When working out, the bar must pull down smoothly towards your chest. If you cannot pull the bar down this far, the weights are too heavy. If you can easily pull it lower, the resistance is too light. Doing the pulldown motions improperly can lead to muscle sprains and tears.

Verdict

Not one of the mentioned workouts is better than the other, with the only exception of the straight arm pulldown providing a more isolated lat workout. Any act of pulling an object with an amount of weight will trigger your lat muscles. Regardless of whether you pull the object from above or in front of your body, the muscles are activated by the pulling motion.

References

Article reviewed by David Fisher Last updated on: Sep 12, 2011

Must see: Photo Galleries

Member Comments