The 10 Best Pain Relief Creams, According to Doctors

LIVESTRONG.com may earn compensation through affiliate links in this story.
The best pain relief cream for you depends on the type of pain you're dealing with.
Image Credit: monstArrr_/iStock/GettyImages

Sore shoulder? Achy knee? If ice or hot packs don't seem to be helping, an over-the-counter topical pain relief cream can offer more serious soothing power.

"When used after proper evaluation, they can be effective in various chronic pain conditions, not just limited to back pain or arthritis," Vivek Mehta, MD, pain management physician at Texas Health Arlington Memorial Hospital, tells LIVESTRONG.com. "In many situations, they have excellent tolerability because of low systemic absorption of drugs and usually a low incidence of side effects."

But with so many options to choose from, it can be tough to tell whether a cream in question will give you the relief you need. Here are 10 expert-backed picks that deliver, plus tips on buying the best pain relief cream and using it safely.

1. Best Overall: Greaseless BENGAY Pain Relieving Cream

Image Credit: Bengay/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

Minor aches and pains or the occasional sprain or strain respond to creams like BENGAY, which contains a local anesthetic plus a soothing agent, says Medhat Mikhael, MD, pain management specialist and medical director of the non-operative program at the Spine Health Center at MemorialCare Orange Coast Medical Center in Fountain Valley, California.

"It has an analgesic effect with cold and a vasodilating effect with heat that improve healing and blood supply to the area, with an added local anesthetic to numb the area," he says.

Another benefit? The formulation is non-greasy, so it feels good on your skin and won't leave stains on clothing.

Buy it:Amazon.com; ​Price: ​$11.99

2. Best for Back Pain: Amazon Basic Care Arthricream

Image Credit: Amazon/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

"Topical formulations are made with a base and active ingredient, which can be optimized for a particular site on the body," Dr. Mehta says.

This one uses trolamine salicylate, a pain reliever related to aspirin that can help numb minor aches and soreness, including back soreness, according to Harvard Health Publishing. The addition of aloe leaf gel makes for an extra-soothing feel.

Buy it:Amazon.com; ​Price: ​$4.10

3. Best for Arthritis: Voltaren Arthritis Pain Relief Gel

Image Credit: Voltaren/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

For joint pain due to osteoarthritis, Dr. Mikhael likes creams containing diclofenac, like this gel from Voltaren. The non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) has been shown to be as effective at relieving arthritis pain and stiffness as well as oral NSAIDs with fewer risks and side effects, according to the Arthritis Foundation.

In the past, Voltaren was only available by prescription. But now a version containing 1 percent diclofenac is available over the counter. The gel formulation isn't greasy, and the twist cap is designed to be easy to open with sore, stiff hands and wrists.

Buy it:Walmart.com; ​Price: ​$9.97

4. Best for Shingles: Zostrix Maximum Strength Natural Pain Relief

Image Credit: Zostrix/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

Capsaicin-based creams are a good option for easing the shooting, burning pain near the surface of your skin that can strike during or after a shingles infection, Dr. Mikhael says. The ingredient, which is derived from chili peppers, is thought to make nerves less sensitive to pain messages, according to a January 2017 Cochrane review.

With 0.1 percent capsaicin to deliver warm, penetrative relief, Zostrix fits the bill. The non-greasy formula feels good on skin and won't stain clothes, and because it's fragrance-free, it's less likely to cause irritation.

Buy it:Amazon.com; ​Price: ​$19.36

5. Best Cold Therapy: Biofreeze Cream

Image Credit: Biofreeze/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

Topicals like Biofreeze that feel cold on the skin can have an instant pain-relieving effect, says Dr. Mikhael. The non-greasy, NSAID-free cream contains menthol, which relieves discomfort by desensitizing nerves and reducing blood flow to sore or injured areas.

And chances are, it'll be more soothing than a bag of frozen peas. A June 2012 study in the ​International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy​ found that menthol is more effective at easting muscle soreness and discomfort compared to simply icing the area.

Buy it:Walgreens.com; ​Price: ​$11.99

6. Best Hot Therapy: Flexpower Pain Relief Lotion Warm

Image Credit: Flexpower/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

This scent-free cream uses trolamine salicylate and methylsulfonylmethane (MSM) to temporarily numb discomfort while delivering a soothing, warming sensation that builds up a few minutes after applying.

It's a multitasker designed to work for everything from post-exercise soreness to arthritis. Just be sure to wash your hands well after applying so you don't accidentally end up rubbing your eyes — they'll definitely feel the burn.

Buy it:Flexpower.com; ​Price: ​$36

7. Best Hot-Cold Therapy: Icy Hot Max Strength Pain Relief Cream With Lidocaine

Image Credit: Icy Hot/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

Some people find that alternating hot and cold therapy delivers more comfort than using either alone. If you're among them, this cream is for you. It uses menthol to deliver a cooling sensation, plus the numbing agent lidocaine, which temporarily stops nerves from sending pain signals, according to the U.S. National Library of Medicine.

Icy Hot's particularly popular for backaches and arthritis-related pain, but it's an all-purpose cream that you can use to tackle soreness from head to toe. The non-greasy formula doesn't feel slick, either.

Buy it:CVS.com; ​Price: ​$10.49

8. Best on a Budget: Tiger Balm Extra Strength Pain Relieving Ointment

Image Credit: Tiger Balm/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

This classic ointment uses a combo of camphor and menthol to create a cooling sensation that temporarily blocks out feelings of discomfort, per Harvard Health Publishing.

Because the ingredients merely mask pain, the balm isn't likely to be as effective as options that also contain anti-inflammatory agents like lidocaine or diclofenac. But it'll get the job done if you're looking for fast, inexpensive, temporary relief.

Buy it:Walgreens.com; ​Price: ​$4.79

9. Best Homeopathic: Penetrex Joint & Muscle Therapy

Image Credit: Penetrex/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

This popular cream gets its pain-fighting power from arnica, a homeopathic remedy that may be helpful for easing muscle and joint discomfort, particularly when it comes to back pain, according to the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health.

Keep in mind that homeopathic remedies aren't subject to the same scientific scrutiny as conventional pain relievers. But this might be worth a try if you're looking for a more natural option, as long as you get the green light from your doctor first.

Buy it:Amazon.com; ​Price: ​$18.95

10. Best for a Massage: Free-Up Professional Massage Cream

Image Credit: Free-Up/LIVESTRONG.com Creative

This smooth, non-greasy lubricant doesn't contain any active pain-relieving ingredients. Instead, it's designed to act as a friction-reducer for massages — another tactic for soothing tight, overworked muscles.

Use the hypoallergenic, fragrance-free cream on your hands to get a deeper rub on areas like your knees, feet or wrists, or hand the jar to your partner or friend for help with your back, shoulders or neck.

Buy it:Amazon.com; ​Price: ​$59.50 (for two 16-oz jars)

What to Look for in a Pain Relief Cream

With so many options out there, it can be tough to know which jar or tube will give you the most bang for your buck. Here are some considerations that can help you zero in on the best product for you.

1. Read the Active Ingredients

Topicals containing NSAIDs like lidocaine or diclofenac work by reducing inflammation, which can help address the root of your discomfort. Other ingredients work by delivering a distracting sensation:

  • Cooling:​ Menthol, methyl salicylate and camphor
  • Warming:​ Capsaicin

All can be effective for helping you manage your pain, depending on the type of relief you're looking for, according to the Cleveland Clinic.

2. Think About the Best Delivery Method

Creams, sprays and patches all relieve pain via the same active ingredients, but certain delivery methods might work better on different parts of the body. Creams and gels are best for areas that move a lot, like your hands, elbows or knees. Patches, on the other hand, will stay put and deliver steady pain relief to places like your back, neck or shoulders. Looking for something that's less messy to apply? Try a spray.

3. Talk With Your Doc About Combo Treatments

Sometimes a pain cream or gel is all you need. But if that's not cutting it, ask your provider about ways to make your topical work harder.

"A combination of topicals and systemic medications like acetaminophen or NSAIDs can be effective for acute pain," Dr. Mikhael says.

Related Reading

How Pain Relief Creams Work

Topical medications like creams, gels, patches and sprays get absorbed through your skin. Some rely on active ingredients like non-steroidal anti-inflammatory agents (NSAIDs) or lidocaine to reduce inflammation and promote healing.

Others use agents like capsaicin, menthol or menthol salicylate to create a warming or cooling sensation that can help distract you from the pain, according to the Mayo Clinic. Cooling agents can also reduce blood flow to a painful area, while warming agents can help dilate blood vessels and encourage more blood flow — two things that can also help promote healing, explains Dr. Mikhael.

Topicals tend to do a good job at helping people bounce back from acute pain near the surface of the skin — like post-workout soreness in your knees or a pulled neck muscle from sleeping the wrong way. While they can sometimes be helpful for managing chronic discomfort, like arthritis or chronic low back pain, they're rarely able to get rid of the pain completely, according to the Cleveland Clinic.

Safety FYIs

Over-the-counter pain creams are generally considered safe. But as with all medications, it's worth taking a few precautions.

1. Only Use Pain Relief Creams Short-Term

Most topicals are designed to be used for no more than a week at a time, per the Cleveland Clinic.

2. Watch for Side Effects

Stop using a cream if you notice redness, a rash, itching or other signs of irritation.

3. Beware of Herbal or Unproven Ingredients

Stick with topicals containing ingredients that have been shown to be both safe and effective, Dr. Mehta recommends. "I'd highly recommend staying away from so-called natural products. Their effects often aren't studied and adverse effects are not catalogued," he says.

4. Talk With Your Doctor About Stubborn Pain

Let your provider know if a topical isn't helping or the pain gets worse, the Cleveland Clinic says. You may need to kick things up a notch with a prescription cream.

Is This an Emergency?

If you are experiencing serious medical symptoms, please see the National Library of Medicine’s list of signs you need emergency medical attention or call 911. If you think you may have COVID-19, use the CDC’s Coronavirus Self-Checker before leaving the house.
references