6 Questions to Ask Yourself Before You Trust That Online Diet Advice

Always consider the source before trusting any diet advice you find online.
Image Credit: Cecilie_Arcurs/E+/GettyImages

You use Google these days for pretty much everything, so chances are you've used it to get some diet advice, too. Almost a third of 20-somethings and 30-somethings, for example, rely on the internet to help them lose weight, according to a 2013 Pew Research Survey.


But while it's perfectly fine to crowdsource low-carb recipes from Facebook, you want to be selective about the diet advice you get from cyberspace. "A lot of the information you'll find online is very general and doesn't take into account your specific medical history, medications and lifestyle," explains Rahaf Al Bochi, RDN, LD, spokesperson for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics and owner of Olive Tree Nutrition LLC in Atlanta.

Video of the Day

Video of the Day

Plus, if you follow an extreme diet or even take a so-called weight-loss supplement without checking with your doctor, it can cause some serious damage. Case in point: In October 2019, the Food and Drug Administration issued a warning about Skinny Pill, a popular diet supplement sold online, because it was found to contain DMAA, an illegal amphetamine linked to high blood pressure and even heart attack.

Of course, the internet can be a wonderful resource, too, when it comes to weight-loss advice. The key is to know what to look for and recognize when a red flag pops up. In that spirit, here's your expert-backed, scam-proof checklist, featuring six questions that can help you determine if the advice that turns up in your Google search, community forum or social media feed is actually legit.

1. What's the Source Here?

When you land on a web page, the first thing you should look for is an "about us" or an "about me" section. Ideally, the site should be run by the federal government, a nonprofit, a professional organization or a medical hospital or institution. (These sites all tend to end in ".gov," ".edu," or ".org.") Or it could be a consumer site, like LIVESTRONG.com, that transparently cites information from these sources and quotes experts in the field.


If, on the other hand, the site is run by someone who claims to have lost an incredible amount of weight by following a miracle diet or simply by popping supplements, it's time to log off, says Al Bochi.

The website should also provide a way to contact the group or webmaster. If it doesn't, be careful.

Reputable sites for diet information include:




2. Is There Any Scientific Proof?

If a site makes health claims that seem too good to be true then, well, they probably are. Be wary of claims that a certain product or weight loss plan is a "breakthrough," or that it relies on a secret, miracle ingredient.

"Try to get past the hype of the marketing and advertisements, and be sure to look deeper to see if there is any research or real scientific evidence to back up the testimonials," says Paul Stricker, MD, a physician with the Scripps Clinic in San Diego and a health advisory board member for Juice Plus+.


If the website cites studies, make sure that they were double-blinded, controlled studies, which means one group got the product in question, while another group didn't. "If something is going into your body, it's worth the extra effort to determine safety and its overall effectiveness," explains Dr. Stricker.

Read more:Are Supplements Safe? Here's What You Really Need to Know


3. Are Credentialed Experts Involved?

That influencer hawking her wares on Instagram may have a gorgeous website and thousands of followers, but if she doesn't have a background in medicine or nutrition, her advice is moot. "Always look for quotes from professionals credentialed in a specific area of expertise from a science-based organization — for example, a registered dietitian credentialed by the Commission on Dietetic Registration, or a certified personal trainer credentialed by the American College of Sports Medicine," advises Jaime Schwartz Cohen, RD, director of nutrition at Ketchum Public Relations.


Credentialed experts are more likely to be promoting weight-loss strategies that have real science-based research behind them, and they're also required to follow a professional code of ethics.


If you want to use a nutrition or weight-loss coach that you've found online, make sure he or she has got all the appropriate state licensing and credentials. If she's a nutritionist, for example, she should be an RD who is licensed by her state.

4. Is It Up to Date?

Nutrition and diet information is constantly changing, so make sure that the information you're reading is current, advises the U.S. National Library of Medicine. Ideally, all information should have been updated within the past year.

If there's no date on the page, take it with a grain of salt. A lot of broken links is another tipoff that the site's not in tune with the times.

Read more:4 Types of Diets to Avoid if Long-Term Weight Loss Is Your Goal

5. Is My Privacy at Risk?

Before you give your email address or other personal info to any website, make sure to check its privacy policy (look for a link that says "privacy."). If the site informs you that it shares your information with other companies, then your information isn't really private and you're probably going to see your email inbox overflowing with spam.

There's also never, ever any reason to give credit card information to a health information website, adds Dr. Stricker. If the site requires a payment or subscription before releasing any details about its plan, process or supplement, skip it.

6. Would My Doctor Agree With This?

Facebook, Twitter and Instagram are all great for social support when you're starting a new diet or weight-loss plan, but keep in mind that just because a post is from a friend doesn't necessarily mean it's accurate. Check the source of the information, and make sure it's credible. When in doubt, always run it by your doctor — that's what he or she is there for, after all.

Read more:How to Tell if a Nutrition or Weight-Loss Story Is Legit




Report an Issue

screenshot of the current page

Screenshot loading...