Elliptical vs. Bike: Which Is Best for Weight Loss?

The elliptical machine works your upper and lower body at the same time.
Image Credit: Jamie Grill/Tetra images/GettyImages

If you're going to spend the time and effort it takes to complete a cardio workout, it's important to weigh the pros and cons of a stationary bike vs. an elliptical, particularly if you're trying to lose weight.

Video of the Day

While it mostly comes down to access, personal preference and which one you'll stick with consistently, an elliptical works both arms and legs, while the stationary bike works your legs and core. Both machines are ideal options for low-impact cardio workouts.

Advertisement

Stationary Bike vs. Elliptical

Stationary Bike

Elliptical

Type of Workout

Cardio

Cardio

Calories Burned

335 in 30 minutes

260 to 391 in 30 minutes

Adjustable

Resistance

Resistance and incline

Targets

Lower body and Core

Full body

Low-Impact

Yes

Yes

Downside

Uncomfortable seat

Requires balance and coordination

Benefits of Elliptical Machines

Elliptical machines are a popular choice for cardio as they're a cross between a stair stepper and a ski machine. They work your legs in a circular up-and-down motion while also working your arms with the moveable handles. You can adjust the resistance and incline to match your fitness level.

1. Burn Calories:​ Using the elliptical machine is a great way to burn calories. According to Harvard Health Publishing, a 155-pound person will burn 335 calories in 30 minutes.

Advertisement

2. Full-Body Workout:​ The movable poles or handles work your arms and shoulders, while your lower body (hamstrings, quadriceps and glutes) gets an intense workout too. You can also cycle your legs backward instead of forward, which will challenge your hamstrings and calves to a greater extent, per the Mayo Clinic. The elliptical engages your core muscles as well.

3. Low-Impact:​ This machine puts less stress on your joints than running, per the Mayo Clinic, making it ideal for those who have knee or hip injuries or arthritis. This kind of low-impact workout is great for cross-training for long-distance runners as it may help prevent stress fractures.

Advertisement

The downside is that if you have balance issues, the circular motion of the legs may be difficult to perform.

Related Reading

Benefits of an Exercise Bike

An exercise bike, or stationary bike, is another great machine for getting a cardiovascular workout. It requires little coordination and the resistance can be adjusted to make it more difficult and force your muscles to work harder.

1. Burns Calories:​ The number of calories you burn can vary depending on how fast you're cycling. In general, a 155-pound person can burn 260 calories when pedaling at a moderate speed for 30 minutes, per Harvard Health Publishing. If you bump it up to a vigorous speed, you'll burn 391 calories in half an hour.

Advertisement

2. Low-Impact Lower-Body Workout:​ A stationary bike is a great way to strengthen your legs and core without stressing your joints, according to the Mayo Clinic. Cycling, in general, is beneficial for those with osteoarthritis.

3. Versatile Workout:​ You can either cycle at home, go to the gym or attend spinning classes if you enjoy group exercise. The bike seat can be uncomfortable, but adding a padded model will often fix this issue.

Related Reading

Bottom Line: Stationary Bike vs. Elliptical for Weight Loss

When used at high-intensity, a stationary bike burns slightly more calories than the elliptical, potentially making it a better choice for those trying to lose weight. The elliptical, however, helps strengthen both your upper and lower body.

Both machines are considered low-impact, making them ideal for those with joint problems as well as for cross-training. The elliptical machine is more weight-bearing than the stationary bike, so it may help improve bone density. But if you have knee, hip or ankle pain, the stationary bike might be a better choice for getting a cardiovascular workout without stressing the joints.

Whichever machine you choose, it's important you work to get your heart rate in the target zone, according to the American Heart Association. To find your maximum heart rate, take 220 and subtract your age. Try to get your heart rate at 50 to 85 percent of your maximum heart rate, depending on your workout intensity.

For example, if you're 40 years old, then your maximum heart rate is 180 beats per minute (bpm). While working out, your heart rate should be between 90 and 153 bpm. If it's lower than that, push yourself a little more. If it's too high, back off the intensity.

If you can't decide between elliptical versus bike, you can use either machines to get a fantastic cardio workout. Plus, it's a great way to keep your routine varied.

Advertisement

references