Olay vs. Neutrogena: Dermatologists Weigh in on Which Skin-Care Brand Is Best

LIVESTRONG.com may earn compensation through affiliate links in this story.
When it comes to skin-care products, seek out options that cater to your skin type and your concerns, from sun protection to reducing acne to boosting hydration.
Image Credit: Renata Angerami/E+/GettyImages

Your skin is the largest organ in your body. That means paying attention to your skin-care routine doesn't just affect your outer appearance — it's also helps safeguard your skin from inflammatory conditions (think: acne) and protect your skin from the sun's rays.

Advertisement

Video of the Day

"The skin functions to help keep moisture in and keep irritants and pathogens out, so it is important to maintain the integrity of the skin barrier, which can be done with the proper use of skin-care products that are gentle on the skin barrier and help to nourish and support it," says Marisa Garshick, MD, a dermatologist at Medical Dermatology & Cosmetic Surgery in New York.

All that's to say that skin-care products are important to your skin health — but if you're overwhelmed by the volume of available options, that's understandable. To ease your search, keep these considerations in mind:

Advertisement

  • Your skin type:​ This is a great starting point when you're choosing a product. For example, if your skin is oily, Dr. Garshick recommends ingredients like salicylic acid, which can be helpful to absorb excess oil, while if your skin is dry, she suggests ingredients that help moisturize the skin, like hyaluronic acid.
  • Your skin-care concerns:​ "There may be different active ingredients to consider if you are trying to address certain skin-care concerns," Dr. Garshick says. That is, people with acne-prone skin will have different needs than those with dry skin, she says. "Those looking to help calm redness may not necessarily need an ingredient or product that helps with hyperpigmentation."

Advertisement

Tip

Of course, it's not unusual to have multiple skin-care concerns. You may, for instance, be eager to protect yourself from the sun, while also reducing breakouts. If you have several skin priorities, seek out an ingredient that can help address more than one issue, Dr. Garshick says. Introduce new ingredients one at a time to get a sense of benefits, she says.

Olay and Neutrogena are two very popular over-the-counter skin-care brands. Both offer many skin benefits. Depending on the type of product you're looking for (e.g., face wash, serum, SPF and so on) along with your particular skin needs, one option may work better for you than the other.

Here, dermatologists share their best recommendations for which brand to choose in some of the most popular skin-care categories.

Advertisement

Acne

Acne is often associated with teens and young adults, but can affect people of all ages.

Neutrogena

Neutrogena has many products available with active ingredients that are helpful for those with acne-prone skin including salicylic acid, benzoyl peroxide and retinol, Dr. Garshick says.

Advertisement

Products include cleansers, topical creams, spot treatments and masks — and, the brand also has makeup products that are good for people with acne-prone skin, she says.

"It is important to remember that those with acne can also benefit from gentle cleansers and moisturizers that are oil-free, so even some of the products that do not contain active ingredients such as salicylic acid can be helpful for those with acne-prone skin," Dr. Garshick says.

Advertisement

Buy it:​

  • Neutrogena Stubborn Acne AM Treatment​ (Walmart, $10.87; Target, $13.79; Amazon, $10.33)
  • Neutrogena Oil-Free Salicylic Acid Acne Fighting Face Wash​ (Amazon, from $33.53 for a three-pack; Walmart, $7.57)
  • Neutrogena On-the-Spot Acne Treatment, 2.5% Benzoyl Peroxide​ (Walmart, $6.99; Amazon, $10.90)

Olay

While Olay does have products that contain acne-targeting ingredients, including salicylic acid and retinol, their line of acne products is much smaller than that of Neutrogena, which is why most dermatologists recommend Neutrogena in this category.

Plus, Olay doesn't offer all of the product categories that Neutrogena does, such as a spot treatment.

Advertisement

Buy it:​

  • Olay Salicylic Acid Booster Serum ​(Walmart, $9.97)
  • Olay Regenerist Detoxifying Pore Scrub Face Wash​ (Target, $7.49; Walmart, $7.48; Amazon, $8.35)
  • Olay Deep Gel Cleanser with Tea Tree Essential Oil​ (Amazon, $11.87)

Anti-Aging

There are a few ingredients to look for when it comes to anti-aging products. Brendan Camp, MD, a Manhattan-based dermatologist at MDCS Dermatology, lays out a list:

  • Retinol​, which help increase collagen
  • Vitamin C​, an antioxidant that neutralizes unstable oxygen radicals
  • Hyaluronic acid​, which helps draw moisturize to the skin
  • Sun protection​ (aka SPF) to slow the formation of fine lines, wrinkles and dark spots

Advertisement

Neutrogena

Neutrogena has all of the ingredients Dr. Camp highlights as being important for anti-aging available in a plethora of products, including night creams, under-eye creams and serums.

Buy it:​

  • Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Retinol Anti-Wrinkle Night Moisturizer Cream ​(Amazon, $20.37)
  • Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Regenerating Cream​ (Ulta, $36.99; Amazon, $25.49)
  • Neutrogena Triple Age Repair Anti-Aging Daily Facial Moisturizer​ (Amazon, $19.47; Walmart, $19.47)

Olay

Olay, too, has anti-aging products that include key ingredients such as retinol and vitamin C. "Additional ingredients include peptides to help boost moisture and firm the skin, as well as hyaluronic acid," Dr. Garshick says.

Both Olay and Neutrogena are effective, and offer "great science-backed OTC anti-aging options" in the anti-aging category, Dr. Garshick says. When you're choosing a brand, "ultimately it comes down to personal preference based on the feel and tolerability of the product," she says.

Buy it:​​

  • Olay Face Serum by Age Defying Anti-Wrinkle 2-in-1 Day Cream Plus Face Serum​ (Amazon, $13.48; Walmart, $14.98)
  • Night Cream by Olay Regenerist Night Recovery Anti-Aging Face Moisturizer​ (Amazon, $20.54; Ulta, $36.99)
  • Olay Eyes Pro Retinol Eye Cream​ (Amazon, $15; Walmart, $18.83)

Moisturizer

Regardless of brand, check if a moisturizer is oil-based or not, Dr. Camp recommends.

"Oil-based moisturizers tend to be a little heavier because they coat the top layer of skin with a thin layer of oil to repair any damage to the top layer of skin and seal in moisture," Dr. Camp says. "Those with naturally oily skin may prefer an oil-free moisturizer, often referred to as a gel or water-based moisturizer; these products tend to be lighter and great for use in the summer when the skin dryness is often less of an issue."

Neutrogena

Neutrogena offers a number of moisturizers to choose from, targeting a variety of skin needs and containing a blend of effective ingredients including ceramides, hyaluronic acid and glycerin. One thing those ingredients have in common: moisture. Ceramides are lipids, while both hyaluronic acid and glycerin are humectants, per the American Academy of Dermatology Association (AAD).

Buy it:​​

  • Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hyaluronic Acid Hydrating Gel-Cream Face Moisturizer​ (Amazon, $19.59; Walmart, $17.99)
  • Neutrogena Deep Moisture Face Cream SPF 20​ (Amazon, $10.07; Walmart, $25.35)
  • Neutrogena Oil-Free Moisture With Broad Spectrum SPF 15 Sunscreen​ (Amazon, $10.48)

Olay

Olay also makes great products for moisturizing.

"Their moisturizing products contain hyaluronic acid to help plump and boost moisture, such as the Olay Regenerist Hyaluronic + Peptide 24," Dr. Garshick says. They also offer products that are formulated for sensitive skin and non-comedogenic, meaning they won't clog pores.

Tip:​ "Moisturizers should be applied as a last step in a skin-care routine, [just] prior to sunscreen in the morning," Dr. Garshick says.

Buy it:​​

  • Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Cream Face Moisturizer​ (Amazon, $18.88; Walmart, $19.35)
  • Olay Complete Lotion Moisturizer Sensitive Skin​ (Target, $12.39; Amazon, $21.98 for a two-pack)
  • Olay Regenerist Vitamin C + Peptide 24 Max Face Moisturizer​ (Walgreens, $46.99)

Cleanser

The general guideline for washing your face is twice daily (plus after perspiring), according to the AAD.

Neutrogena

Neutrogena offers a plethora of face washes that cater to every skin type and need, including acne-prone skin, oily or dry skin and mature skin.

"Keep in mind that if you already have a number of products in your skin care regimen you may only need a basic gentle cleanser; including too many products or active ingredients in your routine can cause skin irritation in the form of dryness, redness, peeling or itching," Dr. Camp says.

Neutrogena also offers cleansers in all different types, including gel, cream and exfoliating.

Buy it:​

  • Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Gel Facial Cleanser & Makeup Remover Face Wash for Sensitive Skin​ (Amazon, $7.19)
  • Neutrogena Oil-Free Salicylic Acid Acne Fighting Face Wash​ (Target, $7.69)
  • Neutrogena Hydro Boost Exfoliating Cleanser​ (Amazon, $10.48)

Olay

Olay cleansers are especially great for someone concerned about anti-aging, as many of the cleansers multi-task, incorporating ingredients such as retinol, vitamin C and hyaluronic acid, Dr. Garshick says.

As with Neutrogena, Olay also offers cleansers in varying types to accommodate personal preference, including creams and exfoliating scrubs.

Buy it:​

  • Olay Regenerist Cream Face Wash with Vitamin C and BHA​ (Target, $7.49)
  • Olay Regenerist Vitamin C + Peptide 24 Exfoliating Facial Cleanser​ (Target, $7.49; Walmart, $7.47)
  • Olay Pore Perfecting Face Scrub​ (Amazon, $7.48)

Serums

Serums, which are usually applied after cleansing but before moisturizing, are lightweight, easily absorbed products that deliver a high concentration of key ingredients for improved penetration, Dr. Camp says.

Neutrogena

"Neutrogena produces serums to help address skin-care concerns such as dryness, acne, wrinkles, dark spots and collagen production," Dr. Camp says. That variety of serum options stands in a bit of contrast to Olay.

Buy it:​

  • Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Hyaluronic Acid Serum​ (Amazon, $11.14)
  • Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Retinol Pro+ .5% Power Serum​ (Walmart, $32.67)
  • Neutrogena Rapid Tone Repair Vitamin C Serum Capsules​ (Ulta, $39.99)

Olay

Olay's serum offerings are most focused on anti-aging concerns, which target an older demographic that may be interested in prevention and skin preservation, Dr. Camp says.

Still, you can find plenty of options in Olay's offerings — that includes a deep hydration serum, a micro-sculpting serum, a retinol serum and more.

Buy it:​

  • Olay Hyaluronic + Peptide 24 Fragrance-Free Serum​ (Target, $29.99)
  • Olay, Regenerist Retinol 24 Max Night Serum​ (Amazon, $24.99)
  • Olay Vitamin E Oil Serum, Nourishing Hydration Booster​ (Walmart, $9.97)

Sunscreen

Applying sunscreen to your face every day is a must.

There are two types of sunscreen: chemical and physical (aka mineral). "Chemical sunscreens are absorbed into the skin and convert UV radiation to heat energy that is released from the skin," Dr. Camp says. In contrast, physical sunscreen sit on your skin, reflecting UV rays away, he says. Physical sunscreens are made with zinc oxide and titanium.

Neutrogena

Neutrogena offers both varieties of sunscreens, physical and chemical, including sunscreens that don't leave a white cast or shadow on the skin, Dr. Camp says. The brand also has sunscreens that can be used on both the face and body.

Buy it:​​

  • Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Non-Greasy Sunscreen Stick for Face & Body​ (Ulta, $16.99)
  • Neutrogena Beach Defense Spray Sunscreen with Broad Spectrum SPF 70​ (Amazon, $8.99)
  • Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch Sunscreen Lotion​ (Target, $7.99)

Olay

Some of the sunscreens Olay offers have benefits beyond sun protection, including antioxidant protection.

If you're looking for a sunscreen that is more hydrating, you'll probably have better luck with Olay, since their sunscreens tend to be ultra moisturizing and contain ingredients that help protect the skin barrier, including hyaluronic acid, collagen and peptides.

Buy it:​

  • Face Moisturizer by Olay Regenerist Microsculpting Cream With SPF 30 Sunscreen​ (Amazon, $21.24)
  • Olay Regenerist Collagen Peptide 24 Face Moisturizer​ (Amazon, $34.08)
  • Face Moisturizer by Olay Complete Daily Defense All Day Moisturizer With Sunscreen​ (Amazon, $24.68; Ulta, $16.99)

What to Know About Common Skin-Care Ingredients

Start Slow With Retinol

When first starting to use a retinol product, no matter the brand, Dr. Camp recommends starting slow so that your skin develops a tolerance to the ingredient.

"I often recommend patients only use it every third night for a month, then every other night for a month, and then gradually increase the use as tolerated," he says. "This sometimes helps reduce the risk of potential side effects, like redness, dryness and peeling."

Retinol products also make skin more sun-sensitive, so it's crucial that an SPF be part of your skin-care regimen in the morning to help shield skin from the harmful effects of UVA and UVB rays.

Beware of Benzoyl Peroxide Discoloring Sheets and Towels

Products containing benzoyl peroxide, a popular anti-acne ingredient more commonly found in Neutrogena than Olay, can bleach fabrics, turning them a yellow or orange color, Dr. Camp says. "Sometimes it is helpful to use a white set of towels, pillow cases and sheets to avoid this," he says. That way, you can bleach them.

"Using an older set of towels or linens that you have less attachment to is also an option," Dr. Camp says.

Adding More Products Isn't Always Helpful

When it comes to skin health, more products doesn't always mean better results.

"You need to understand your skin needs and what can be helpful," says Mary Alice Mina, MD, Atlanta-based dermatologist and Mohs surgeon. "With skin care, often times less is more as too many products or active ingredients can irritate the skin, or cause allergic reactions." Discussing your skin-care routine with a dermatologist can help you save both time and money, Dr. Mina says.

All in all, when shopping for skin care products, remember that just because something is trending or helpful for one person, doesn't mean it will work for you.

Advertisement

references & resources

Is this an emergency? If you are experiencing serious medical symptoms, please see the National Library of Medicine’s list of signs you need emergency medical attention or call 911.