In the world of bodybuilding, protein is a big deal. You need protein to help your muscles to rebuild and repair themselves after a workout. While foods like beef, tuna, eggs and chicken, along with dairy-based protein powders, are often seen as the go-to muscle-building foods and supplements, those on a plant-based diet may need to look to other ways to get protein, such as with soy protein in food and supplement form.
The Soy and Estrogen Myth
One of the reasons why many wannabe muscle-builders avoid soy protein is because of a belief that soy will increase estrogen and reduce testosterone levels, slowing down muscle growth. A meta analysis published in a 2010 edition of the journal of "Fertility and Sterility," however, concluded that neither soy-based foods nor supplements have a negative impact on testosterone levels.
Soy Vs. Whey Vs. Casein
When compared to whey and casein protein supplements, soy protein powder sits somewhere in the middle in terms of muscle protein synthesis. This is the speed at which protein is used by the muscles, and a higher protein synthesis is beneficial for building muscle. In a study from a 2009 edition of the "Journal of Applied Physiology," soy protein supplementation was inferior to whey hydrolysate in terms of synthesizing protein for muscle, but it performed better than casein protein.
Soy: The Complete Package
Soy is the best form of nonanimal protein, according to Dr. Jose Antonio, head of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. One of the reasons for this is that soy is a complete protein. Most plant-based proteins are what's known as incomplete proteins, meaning they don't contain all the essential amino acids, whereas animal proteins do. This makes soy a superior muscle-builder to other plant-based proteins, as you don't need to combine it with another protein source to make sure you get all the amino acids.
Soy Foods and Non-Soy Supplements
Soy protein can come from different foods, such as soy milk, tofu and edamame, as well as special soy protein powders. Vegan strength athletes and bodybuilders often consume a lot of soy-based foods, notes nutritionist Ryan Andrews, which is fine, but when picking a supplement, you may want to look to a plant-based protein powder not made from soy, to avoid overloading on a single source. Brown rice, hemp and pea protein are all other options.
- Fertility and Sterility: Clinical Studies Show No Effects of Soy Protein or Isoflavones on Reproductive Hormones in Men: Results of a Meta-Analysis
- Journal of Applied Physiology: Ingestion of Whey Hydrolysate, Casein, or Soy Protein Isolate: Effects on Mixed Muscle Protein Synthesis at Rest and Following Resistance Exercise in Young Men
- Mahler's Aggressive Strength: Eating for Maximal Strength, Health, Energy and Muscle
- Columbia Health Go Ask Alice!: Complete and Incomplete Proteins in Grains and Vegetables?
- Body for Life: Protein Powder